Skip to content
Soriaga & Associates, LLC logo

In-House Bookkeeper vs. Outsourced CPA for a Home Health or Hospice Agency

Christian Soriaga, CPA8 min read

On this page

Quick answer: An in-house bookkeeper is a good fit for daily entries, bills and payroll data, but one person rarely covers a home health or hospice agency's full accounting needs. Outsourcing to a CPA firm adds the Medicare cost report, tax work and monthly reports. Many agencies use both: a bookkeeper in the office and a CPA firm on top.

The U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics reports median pay of $50,670 a year for bookkeeping, accounting and auditing clerks (May 2025). Benefits add about 30% to total pay for private industry workers (BLS, June 2026).

If you are deciding between in-house vs outsourced accounting, the question is not only cost. It is what work must get done and who has the skills to do it. This post compares the two for home health and hospice agencies. It is general information, not advice for your agency.

Key takeaways

  • A bookkeeper costs more than the paycheck. Median pay is $50,670 a year (BLS, May 2025), and benefits and employer taxes come on top.
  • A bookkeeper keeps the books. A CPA firm does more. Cost reports, tax planning and CFO-level reports are CPA work.
  • Medicare adds work most bookkeepers have not done. That includes the cost report and, for hospices, the aggregate cap.
  • One person is a single point of failure. Sick days, vacations and turnover stop your books.
  • Outsourced monthly accounting at our firm starts at $800 per month. The exact fee depends on your size and scope.
  • A hybrid often works best. Keep a part-time bookkeeper for daily entries and use a CPA firm for the rest.
  • New agencies pay no setup fee with us. You pay the monthly retainer, and we help set up everything.

Not sure what your agency needs? Book a free 20-minute call and we will tell you plainly, even if the answer is "hire a bookkeeper."

What does an in-house bookkeeper cost?

The U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics (BLS) says the median pay for bookkeeping, accounting and auditing clerks was $50,670 a year in May 2025. That is $24.36 an hour. Median means half of these workers earn more and half earn less. Pay in your city, and for someone who knows healthcare, may be higher.

Pay is only part of the cost. BLS also tracks what employers pay for benefits. For private industry workers, wages were $32.82 an hour and benefits were $14.07 an hour in June 2026. Benefits were 30.0% of total compensation. Benefits there include paid leave, insurance, retirement and legally required items like Social Security and Medicare taxes.

Here is a rough example. If benefits are 30% of total cost, the total is about 1.43 times the pay. A bookkeeper paid $50,670 would cost about $72,400 a year. Illustrative. BLS averages cover all private industry, not one job.

Add software, a computer and your time to hire and manage. Then add what happens when the person leaves or is out sick. Your books may stop for weeks.

Action: Add up pay, benefits, taxes, software and training. That is your true in-house cost.

What does an in-house bookkeeper usually not cover?

A good bookkeeper records transactions, pays bills, sends invoices and reconciles bank accounts. That is real work. But it is not the same as accounting. For the difference between a bookkeeper, an accountant and a CPA, see bookkeeper vs. accountant.

For a Medicare-certified agency, a bookkeeper alone usually does not cover these:

  • The Medicare cost report. Home health agencies file Form CMS-1728-20 and hospices file Form CMS-1984-14. The report is due on or before the last day of the fifth month after your cost reporting period ends (42 CFR 413.24(f)(2)). It has many worksheets and rules about which costs Medicare allows. Few bookkeepers have prepared one.
  • The hospice aggregate cap. Medicare limits what a hospice can be paid in a cap year. If you are paid more than the limit, you owe the difference back (42 CFR 418.309). Someone has to calculate that with real numbers, not at the last minute.
  • Tax planning and filing. Your entity type, owner pay, estimated taxes and year-end moves are tax work. A bookkeeper should not decide them alone.
  • CFO-level reports. Margin by service line, cash forecasts, and budgets versus actuals take more than clean books. They take someone who can explain what the numbers mean.
  • A second set of eyes. When one person enters, approves and reconciles, mistakes and fraud are harder to catch.

The most common problem we fix is not careless work. It is books set up for taxes only, with nothing that maps to cost centers. The cost report then becomes a rebuild.

Action: List the five items above. Mark the ones nobody on your team can do today.

What does outsourcing to a CPA firm cover?

When you outsource to a CPA firm, you get a team instead of one person. At Soriaga & Associates, LLC, a monthly retainer can include:

  • Bookkeeping and monthly close
  • Payroll support
  • Tax planning and filing
  • Medicare cost report support
  • Monthly financial reports you can read

Monthly accounting starts at $800 per month. The exact fee depends on the size and scope of your agency. We confirm it in writing after a free call. The cost report is priced separately: $1,599.99 flat for a low- or full-utilization report and $500 for a no-utilization report.

If you are opening a new agency, there is no setup fee. You pay the $800 per month retainer, and we help set up everything: the chart of accounts, cost center tracking and monthly routines. We work with agencies nationwide, fully remote, and have 20+ years in healthcare accounting.

For more on services and what they include, see our home health accounting and hospice accounting services pages.

Action: Ask any firm you consider for a written scope and fee, including the cost report.

How do in-house and outsourced accounting compare?

In-house bookkeeper Outsourced CPA firm
Cost Pay of $50,670 median (BLS), plus benefits, taxes and software Monthly retainer, from $800 per month at our firm
Daily entries Strong, and on site Handled remotely on a set schedule
Medicare cost report Rarely done in-house Included in scope or priced separately
Hospice cap Needs outside help Part of the review
Tax planning Not usually Yes
If someone is out Books may stop A team covers
Owner reports Depends on the person Monthly reports and meetings
Hiring and training You do it We do it

The table shows a pattern. In-house is strong on day-to-day speed. Outsourcing is strong on skill range and backup. Neither is right for every agency.

Action: Circle the rows that matter most to you. They point to your answer.

When does in-house make sense?

Being fair, in-house is the better choice in some cases. It fits when:

  • You have high volume, such as many daily bills, deposits and staff, and need someone on site every day.
  • You already have a skilled bookkeeper who knows your software and payers.
  • You want someone to handle people and vendors face to face.
  • You still plan to hire a CPA for the cost report and tax work.

That last point is the pattern we see most. A bookkeeper keeps the daily work moving. A CPA firm handles the cost report, taxes and monthly review. You do not have to choose one or the other.

Outsourcing fits better when you are a new or small agency, when your bookkeeper left, when your books are behind, or when you have never had a cost-report-ready set of books. It also fits when you want one firm to be accountable for the whole picture.

Action: Decide which tasks need someone in your office. Outsource the rest.

What we see in practice

Many owners start with a part-time bookkeeper and a tax preparer who does not know Medicare. The books look fine until the cost report is due. Then the owner finds the records are not set up to support it.

The fix is rarely firing anyone. It is adding a CPA firm that knows home health and hospice, so the bookkeeper's work feeds the cost report all year. Our bookkeeping services are built for that.

Weighing a hire against a retainer? Book a free 20-minute call and bring your current books and last cost report. We will compare the options with you.

Frequently asked questions

How much does an in-house bookkeeper cost?

The U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics reports median pay of $50,670 a year ($24.36 an hour) for bookkeeping, accounting and auditing clerks (May 2025). Benefits and employer taxes add to that. BLS data shows benefits are about 30% of total compensation for private industry workers, so the real cost is higher than the pay.

Can an in-house bookkeeper prepare the Medicare cost report?

Some can, but most are not trained to. The cost report has many worksheets and rules about which costs Medicare allows. Many agencies keep a bookkeeper for daily work and hire a CPA firm for the cost report.

What does outsourced accounting cost for a home health or hospice agency?

Monthly accounting at Soriaga & Associates, LLC starts at $800 per month. The exact fee depends on the size and scope of your agency, and we confirm it in writing after a free call. Cost reports are priced separately.

How much is a Medicare cost report?

We charge a flat $1,599.99 for a low- or full-utilization cost report and $500 for a no-utilization report.

Do I need a CPA if I already have a bookkeeper?

Usually yes, for the work a bookkeeper does not do: the Medicare cost report, tax planning, and reviews of margin and cash. You can keep your bookkeeper and add a CPA firm for those parts. To talk it through, book a free call.

Is there a setup fee for a new agency?

No. A new agency pays the monthly retainer, which starts at $800 per month, and we help set up the books, chart of accounts and cost center tracking as part of it.

Do you work with agencies outside Illinois?

Yes. We work with home health and hospice agencies nationwide, working remotely.

Next step

Write down who does each accounting task today: daily entries, payroll, taxes, the cost report and monthly reports. Any task with no clear owner is a gap.

Book a free 20-minute call and we will look at those gaps with you and give you a written fee. Read about home health accounting and hospice accounting services, or call (630) 491-1268.

Sources

Last updated: November 2026.

This article is general information, not legal or tax advice. The worked example is illustrative.

Soriaga & Associates, LLC is a CPA firm founded in 1985 in Lisle, Illinois, serving home health, hospice, home care, wound care and dental providers nationwide. (630) 491-1268.

Keep reading

Free 20-minute call

Let's get your books in order.

Talk directly with Christian Soriaga, CPA. No pitch deck, no obligation.

On the call we’ll cover

  • Your situation and what is due next
  • Deadlines and filing status
  • A clear written fee quote
  • Clear next steps, no obligation

Christian Soriaga, CPA

Soriaga & Associates, LLC

Book a Free Call